Just My Take
by Robert Baker
April 29, 2003
RBN News: UN CHARGES COALITION
WITH ZONING VIOLATIONS
RBN reports that the United Nations has brought suit against
the United States and its Coalition partners. The Secretary-General,
who prefers to be called Koffee Anywan, gave a copy of the
complaint to RBN plus exclusive details on the genesis and
aims of the lawsuit.
The lawsuit lists several zoning violations including failure
to apply for permits to remodel Baghdad, Basra and several
other Iraqi cities and villages; open burning of trash without
approval from the local fire marshal; violation of CAFÉ
mileage standards for tanks and Bradley fighting vehicles;
operation of motorized vehicles without a valid Iraqi driving
permit; possession and discharging of firearms within city
limits; possession of banned semi-automatic assault rifles
and automatic weapons; failure to obtain permits from the
Utilities Commission for extensive excavations near gas, electric,
and sewer lines; violations of local noise abatement ordinances;
failure to file flight plans; cruel and inhumane treatment
of chickens, dolphins, and donkeys; and failure to submit
an environmental impact statement. The list continued for
an additional 17 pages. The civil suit was filed late this
afternoon in US District court in San Francisco. The complaint,
sealed by the Court, followed an extremely rare closed session
of the international organization.
Although the session was closed to the press, RBN has learned
from reliable sources that the case against the Coalition
was made in a three-hour presentation to the member states.
The presentation was followed by 15 minutes of floor debate
before a roll call vote was taken. The vote was 146 - 45 in
favor of proceeding with the lawsuit. (For a complete list
of how each country voted, go to www.genassvote.un.org.com.eu.plo.gvt.)
It has been reported that Canada passed on the first roll
call vote. The Canadian ambassador reportedly agonized for
10 minutes before finally voting in favor of the suit. "It
was a difficult vote," the ambassador said, "but
I hope that eventually our American neighbors will see it
as a principled act of tough love." There were two abstentions:
the Vatican and the International Space Station.
"We were hopeful that we would not have to take this
drastic action," the Sec-Gen said. "We were willing
to give the US some latitude in their war against Iraq. After
all we haven't forgotten September 11th, either. But when
the war dragged on into the second week, we could no longer
ignore the quagmire and mounting violations. The Coalition
resisted diplomatic pressure through private channels. This
was our last resort."
Several organizations and political entities filed amicus
(friend of the court) briefs on behalf of the UN position.
They included Old Europe, ANSWER, the Berkley City Council,
the Screen Actors Guild, PETA, the Sierra Club, the Democratic
National Committee, the Dixie Chicks, Russia, China, the PLO,
and the New York Times.
The suit calls for a judgment against the US primarily and
the Coalition secondarily. The US is to be fined $1 million
for each violation, not to exceed a total fine of $200 billion.
In addition, the cost of the cleanup will be charged to the
Coalition.
The UN will use money from the fines to administer Iraq until
the country is stable enough to elect its own government.
Five percent of the money will go to the Rainbow Coalition
to administer a sensitivity training program for all Coalition
military personnel. Turkey and Russia will be awarded political
administration of the Kurdish areas. The French will govern
southern Iraq. The Germans and Chinese will have the awesome
task of rebuilding the Iraqi Defense Force. A coalition of
Arab states will be responsible for peace keeping. Michael
Moore Productions will be awarded exclusive rights to film
documentaries about the Iraqi struggle.
The UN is asking the court to also ban the Coalition from
Iraq commencing 30 days after the Coalition receives the surrender
of the present Iraqi government. "We want them to have
time to collect their things and for closure," the French
Ambassador is quoted as saying.
"It is not about the money." Koffee said. "We
debated at length about granting financial amnesty to the
Coalition, but finally we concluded that would send the wrong
message. We compromised by placing a cap on the fines. The
Coalition is not above the law. Remember, zoning laws are
there for a reason- your protection. The UN takes your security
seriously. Trusting us will be in your best interest, you'll
see."
©
2003 Tocqevillian Magazine